Same Day Garage Door Services vs A1 Garage Door Service


Choosing a garage door company in the greater Phoenix metro? This page compares Same Day Garage Door Services and A1 Garage Door Service using information each company publishes, public licensing records, and public review platforms. We checked every fact on the date shown next to it. Where A1 Garage Door Service has the edge, we say so. If anything here is out of date or wrong, tell us and we will fix it.
Written by Same Day Garage Door Services. Every figure below was checked against public sources between 17 September and 5 November 2026. Each row gives its own date and links to where we got it. We are not affiliated with A1 Garage Door Service and receive nothing if you choose them.
Which company is right for you
Choose Same Day if
- Family owned The Brown family has owned and run it since 2016.
- Independent ownership Three named family members own us. A1's ownership is cited below.
- Our own crews Never subcontracted. Our technicians are our own employees.
- Fixed quote The price given at your house is the price you pay.
- No upsell pitch Quoted before any work starts. If you decline, you pay only the service call.
A1's ownership: Cortec Group, a private equity firm, says it completed a growth recapitalization of A1 in December 2022, with A1's founder keeping a significant stake. Reuters reported on 2 Sep 2026, citing sources, that KKR has agreed to buy A1 for around $2 billion. Read 5 Nov 2026: Cortec announcement, Reuters report.
Choose A1 if
- Overnight emergencies They describe their emergency service as around the clock. Phone calls answered 24/7. Booking available 24/7.
- Wider coverage They say they cover 70+ markets.
- Online door pricing Their estimator includes financing terms.
- Lifetime spring warranty They offer one on their MaxLife springs.
- More Google reviews Their Phoenix listing has more Google reviews than ours.
Twelve things to compare side by side
We quote their own wording instead of paraphrasing it. Every cell links to where we read it.
Dimension
Same Day
A1
01
Service call fee
Same Day
$69 service call, waived when you go ahead with a repair (parts and labor).
A1
No trip charge figure published. Their Worry-Free Guarantee page lists trip charges among the things it excludes.
Read 8 Oct 2026: guarantee page.
02
Published pricing
Same Day
Eleven jobs priced on our pricing page.
A1
No publicly disclosed pricing for their own repairs. Their cost guide gives general ranges, and their estimator covers new doors.
Read 5 Nov 2026: Phoenix page, cost guide, cost estimator.
03
Online cost estimator
Same Day
None. Free on-site estimate for a new door, at your house.
A1
A new garage door cost estimator on their site, with financing terms built in.
Read 8 Oct 2026: cost estimator.
04
Hours, and what emergency means
Same Day
Phone calls answered 24/7. Booking available 24/7.
A1
Their Phoenix page says they are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week for emergency repair. Their Broadway Road listing showed "Open 24 hours" status on 8 Oct 2026.
Read 8 Oct 2026: Phoenix page, Maps, Broadway Road, Phoenix.
05
Same-day terms, quoted
Same Day
As fast as same day for qualifying services, Monday to Saturday, from offices in Gilbert, Tempe and Mesa.
06
Arizona ROC license
Same Day
ROC 308754 (primary) and ROC 349928. Both active on the state register.
Arizona ROC public record, checked 1 Oct 2026: ROC 308754, ROC 349928.
A1
ROC 276272 and ROC 267827. Both active on the state register.
Arizona ROC public record, checked 1 Oct 2026: ROC 276272, ROC 267827.
07
Local offices
Same Day
Gilbert, Tempe and Mesa.
A1
Their About page says they work across 70+ markets, so the nearest crew depends on the day.
Read 8 Oct 2026: About page.
08
Warranty offered
Same Day
Craftsmanship warranty: 1 year on our labor, for the work we did. +2 warranty: two years added to whatever the manufacturer's warranty is. Warranties do not transfer when the home is sold.
A1
Their warranty terms are tables in their terms and conditions, by product.
Read 8 Oct 2026: terms and conditions.
09
Spring warranty
Same Day
Springs rated for 20,000 to 30,000 cycles. Whatever the manufacturer's warranty is, we add two years to it.
A1
Lifetime warranty on their MaxLife springs, which they say are designed to last up to 80,000 cycles. Their terms list it as limited lifetime: for the original purchaser, while they own the home.
Read 8 Oct 2026: Phoenix page, MaxLife page, terms and conditions.
10
Brands carried
Same Day
Authorized LiftMaster Dealer for openers. Authorized dealer for Amarr, Clopay and 1st UDT doors.
A1
Their Phoenix page says they are an authorized dealer of Clopay, Martin and Linear Pro Access, and lists Wayne Dalton, Amarr and others.
Read 8 Oct 2026: Phoenix page.
11
Google rating and review count
Same Day
Our three Google listings are all rated 5.0, with 5,400+ reviews in all, as of 8 Oct 2026.
A1
4.8 (13,378) at the Broadway Road, Phoenix listing, as of 8 Oct 2026.
Google Maps, observed 8 Oct 2026: Broadway Road, Phoenix.
12
Ownership
Same Day
Independent, owned by three named family members, three offices.
A1
Recapitalized by a private equity group in December 2022. Reuters reported in September 2026 that a larger firm agreed to buy it for around $2 billion; both parties declined to comment. Their own About page says family-owned.
Reuters, 2 Sep 2026, Cortec Group, and their About page, read 8 Oct 2026: Reuters report, Cortec announcement, About page.
You can check any row in about a minute. Their own pages, the Google listings and the state license register are all linked. If a figure we quote is no longer there, our page is out of date and we would like to know.
What customers say in their reviews
Google figures are per listing, read by hand from each public listing on 8 Oct 2026. We show our own figures in the same frame.
Same Day Garage Door Services
- Google, our three listings
- 5.0 · 5,400+as of 8 Oct 2026
- Yelp
- 4.8 · 398as of 5 Nov 2026View on Yelp
- BBB rating
- A+, accredited since 2017as of 5 Nov 2026View on BBB
- BBB complaints, 3 years
- 0as of 5 Nov 2026View on BBB
What reviews show, including complaints
- Reviewers name their technician in nearly half of our reviews. That is why our guides carry bylines.
- Reviewers often say the price on the invoice matched the price quoted on the phone.
A1 Garage Door Service
- Google, Broadway Road, Phoenix
- 4.8 · 13,378as of 8 Oct 2026
- Yelp
- 3.3 · 1,220as of 5 Nov 2026View on Yelp
- BBB rating
- A+, accredited since 2010as of 5 Nov 2026View on BBB
- BBB complaints, 3 years
- 152, none unansweredas of 5 Nov 2026View on BBB
Themes in the public record
- No BBB pattern-of-complaint alert is on file.
- Their dispute terms require individual binding arbitration and include a class action waiver. This is on their own terms page, which is linked.
- Google figures were read by hand from each public listing on 8 Oct 2026. Ratings and counts change, so each one links to its listing.
- Review themes are sampled from the newest reviews and the topics Google lists for a listing. They are not a full analysis of every review.
- "Open 24 hours" is the hours status a Google Maps listing displayed. It is not a verified dispatch or staffing policy.
- BBB figures were read from each company's public BBB profile on 5 Nov 2026. Yelp does not allow automated reads, so Yelp figures are as its listings appeared in search results that day, and the live listing may differ.
- We list complaint themes only for ourselves. Read A1's listing for theirs.
Where A1 is the better choice
- Overnight repairs They describe emergency repair around the clock, and their listing showed "Open 24 hours" status on 8 Oct 2026. Phone calls answered 24/7. Booking available 24/7.
- Far more reviews Their Broadway Road listing showed 4.8 (13,378) on 8 Oct 2026. Our three listings together have 5,400+.
- Online door pricing You can price a door on their site, with financing terms, without talking to anyone. We quote new doors at your door.
- Lifetime spring warranty On their MaxLife springs, for as long as you own the home. They say the springs are designed for up to 80,000 cycles, and ours are rated for fewer.
- Wider coverage They cover areas we do not. Our offices are in Gilbert, Tempe and Mesa.

Where Same Day is the better choice
- Three local offices Our offices are in Gilbert, Tempe and Mesa.
- Priced job by job Eleven jobs priced on our pricing page.
- Zero BBB complaints In three years, as of 5 Nov 2026.

Why customers choose us
- Family-owned and based in the greater Phoenix metro since 2016.
- Licensed by the Arizona Registrar of Contractors: AZ ROC 308754 and AZ ROC 349928.
- You approve the price before any work starts.
Check any of this yourself
These sources take about five minutes to check. Pick any two rows and look them up.
- Arizona ROC license lookupSearch either company by name or license number. It shows the license class, its status, and any complaints on file. Ours are ROC 308754 and ROC 349928.
- A1's Google listing, and oursRatings and review counts change. On 8 Oct 2026 our three Google listings were all rated 5.0, with 5,400+ reviews in all. We link to theirs so you can see today's figures instead of the ones we read.
- A1's own websiteEvery row links the page we read it on. If a figure we quote is no longer there, our page is out of date and we would like to know.
- Ask both of us for the spring's cycle ratingA 10,000 cycle spring and a higher-cycle spring look the same but last very different lengths of time. We fit springs rated for 20,000 to 30,000 cycles. Ask any other company which one they would install on your door.
Common questions about this comparison
You should check it for yourself. Every figure here links to where we got it, and we have listed where they are the better choice. Pick any two rows and look them up.
Each row shows the date it was checked. Prices, ratings and review counts change. We update this page from time to time. If you find something out of date, tell us and we will fix it.
No. We have no referral arrangement with A1.
No. We're an independent company and aren't connected to or endorsed by A1 Garage Door Service.
Public sources: their website, the Arizona Registrar of Contractors, the Better Business Bureau and Google Maps, as of the dates shown. Details can change, so confirm anything important with them directly.
A1 is a multi-market brand with a Phoenix listing on Broadway Road. Their About page says they work across 70+ markets. We are family-owned, with offices in Gilbert, Tempe and Mesa.
A1. On 8 Oct 2026 their Broadway Road listing showed 4.8 (13,378). Our three Google listings are all rated 5.0, with 5,400+ reviews in all.
Yes, on our pricing page. A service call is $69, waived when you go ahead with a repair (parts and labor).
Ours are ROC 308754 and ROC 349928. A1's records on the state register are ROC 276272 and ROC 267827. Each is linked in the table above.
Financing is available through Service Finance, a third-party lender, subject to their approval. There is a $1,000 minimum, and it applies to any job. We do not finance in-house.
Warranties do not transfer when the home is sold.
Repair. Springs, cables, tracks, sensors and doors that will not open or close. Openers. Opener repair and new opener installation. New doors. New garage doors for your home, with an estimate at your house. We also do commercial work.
Still deciding? Give us a call.
Ask us anything about your job. If we are not the right fit, we will tell you on the phone, before anyone comes to your house.
A1 Garage Door Service and all other company names, trademarks and brand names on this page belong to their respective owners. They are used only to identify those companies for comparison. Same Day Garage Door Services is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by A1 Garage Door Service. Information about A1 Garage Door Service comes from its public website, the Arizona Registrar of Contractors, the Better Business Bureau and Google Maps, as of the dates shown, and may have changed since. Prices, warranties, hours and ratings can change at any time; confirm details directly with each company. Same Day Garage Door Services is licensed by the Arizona Registrar of Contractors, ROC 308754 and ROC 349928. If you believe anything on this page is inaccurate, contact us at (480) 750-7975 and we will review and correct it promptly.
