Decision guide
Repair or replace your garage door
We do both. Here is what each costs on our price list, what our warranty covers on each, and the signs that point one way or the other.
Written by Same Day Garage Door Services. Our prices come from our published price list. Every outside fact was read on its source on 8 October 2026, and each one links to where we got it.
Which way your door points
Repair if
- The door is sound and one part has failed: a spring, a cable, a roller.
- The door came off its track. An off-track repair is from $199 on our price list.
- The opener runs but a part has failed: the board, gear and sprocket, capacitor or receiver. Opener repair is from $160.
Replace if
- Your opener was made before 1993. The federal entrapment protection standard covers residential openers made on or after 1 January 1993.
- You want a new style or insulation. We are an authorized dealer for Amarr, Clopay and 1st UDT.
- You want a longer warranty. Our +2 warranty adds two years to the manufacturer's.
Five things to compare
Our prices and terms come from our price list and our published warranty. The opener rule is federal, linked under its row.
Dimension
Repair
Replace
01
Opener
Repair
Opener repair: from $160, for a board, gear and sprocket, capacitor or receiver.
Replace
Opener replacement, installed: from $975.20, for the unit, labor and safety sensors.
Our figures: our price list.
02
Door
Repair
A single torsion spring starts at $286.20 + $160 labor ($446.20 in all). Spring and cable replacement is from $609.50. An off-track repair is from $199.
Replace
Quoted at your door, not listed. Free on-site estimate for a new door.
Our figures: our price list.
03
How long it takes
Repair
As fast as same day for qualifying services, Monday to Saturday.
Replace
In stock doors can be installed as soon as scheduled. Lead times vary by door type and manufacturer, and we give you yours with your quote. The install itself takes one day.
04
Our warranty
Repair
Our craftsmanship warranty covers the labor on the work we did for one year, and it covers only what we worked on. If the job was springs or rollers, the opener failing within that year is not covered by it.
Replace
Whatever the manufacturer's warranty is, we add two years to it. If a new door's manufacturer warranty on the springs is three years, we cover those springs for five years.
Our terms: warranties page.
05
Opener safety standard
Repair
A repair keeps the opener you have, at the age it is.
Replace
A new opener is built to the federal entrapment protection standard, which covers residential openers made on or after 1 January 1993.
Read 8 Oct 2026: 16 CFR 1211.1.
- A service call is $69 when a technician comes out to diagnose. It is waived when you go ahead with a repair (parts and labor).
When repairing is the better choice
When the door is sound and one part has failed. A broken spring, a frayed cable or a door off its track is a repair, and the prices are on our list: a single torsion spring starts at $286.20 + $160 labor ($446.20 in all), and an off-track repair is from $199.
When the opener runs but a part has failed. Opener repair is from $160, while an installed replacement is from $975.20.
When replacing is the better choice
When the opener predates the federal safety standard. It covers residential openers made on or after 1 January 1993, so an older unit was not built to it. A unit built to it carries a label saying it meets the CPSC entrapment protection requirements.
When you want something a repair cannot give you: a new style, insulation or a quieter door. A new door also comes with our +2 warranty. Whatever the manufacturer's warranty is, we add two years to it.
Check any of this yourself
Every outside fact on this page comes from one of these. Each takes a minute or two to check.
- Our price listEvery repair and replacement price on this page, with what moves each one.See the price list
- Our warrantiesWhat our craftsmanship warranty and our +2 warranty cover.Read our warranties
- 16 CFR 1211.1The scope of the federal opener safety standard, with its 1993 start date.Read the regulation
- 16 CFR 1211.24The label an opener built to the standard carries.Read the label rule
Common questions about repair or replace
If it runs and one part has failed, repair is usually the cheaper route: from $160 on our price list, while an installed replacement is from $975.20. If it was made before 1993, it predates the federal entrapment protection standard, and replacing it is the better choice.
Look for the label. Federal rules require an opener built to the standard to carry a label saying it meets the CPSC garage door operator entrapment protection requirements, with the date of the standard.
Not on its own. A spring is a part, and replacing it is a repair. A single torsion spring starts at $286.20 + $160 labor ($446.20 in all) on our price list.
It depends on the brand, the size, the insulation and the windows, so we quote it at your door. Free on-site estimate for a new door.
On a repair: Our craftsmanship warranty covers the labor on the work we did for one year, and it covers only what we worked on. On a new door: Whatever the manufacturer's warranty is, we add two years to it.
Not sure which you need?
Tell us what the door or opener is doing. We will tell you whether it is a repair, and what it costs, before anyone touches it.

