Skip to content

Decision guide

Torsion vs extension garage door springs

Most garage doors are lifted by one of two spring types. Here is how they differ, what each costs to replace on our price list, and how to tell which one your door has.

Written by Same Day Garage Door Services. Our prices come from our published price list. Every outside fact was read on its source on 8 October 2026, and each one links to where we got it.

Warning

Safety warning. Garage door springs, cables and bottom brackets are under extreme tension and can cause serious injury or death if they slip or break. This guide is general information only. If your repair involves springs, cables, or brackets, stop and call a licensed professional.

Do not adjust, wind, unwind or replace springs yourself. A torsion spring stores enough energy to break bones. Spring work needs proper winding bars and training. Call a licensed technician: (480) 750-7975.

Never loosen a cable or bottom bracket while the springs are under tension. These parts hold the spring's load. Leave them to a professional.

In Arizona, garage door installation and repair for pay generally requires a contractor license from the Arizona Registrar of Contractors. You can check any company's license at roc.az.gov. Same Day Garage Door Services is licensed: ROC 308754 (primary) and ROC 349928.

Call us instead. A pair of extension springs starts at $338.14 on our price list, and a single torsion spring starts at $286.20 + $160 labor ($446.20 in all).

Call (480) 750-7975

Which spring type fits your situation

Front view from inside. The springs sit on the shaft above the door, with a cable drum at each end.

Torsion springs if

  • You want the longer-lasting spring. Clopay says torsion springs generally last longer, often 10,000 to 20,000 cycles.
  • You want the spring held by its own mounting. DASMA says a torsion spring's shaft inherently provides containment.

Side view, with the front of the garage on the left. The spring runs along the track near the ceiling, with a safety cable through it.

Extension springs if

  • You want the lower figure on our price list. A pair of extension springs starts at $338.14, and a single torsion spring starts at $286.20 + $160 labor ($446.20 in all). Clopay also calls extension springs less expensive.
  • Your door already has them, with a safety cable through each spring. DASMA says that cable is what a door with extension springs needs.

Five things to compare

How each type works is in the manufacturers' and the trade association's own words, linked under each row. The prices are ours.

01

Where it sits

Torsion springs

Above the door. Clopay says torsion springs use a twisting motion to store and release energy.

Extension springs

Along the sides of the door, usually beside the horizontal track. They stretch to lift and lower the door.

Read 8 Oct 2026: Clopay components guide, DASMA terminology (PDF).

02

If a spring breaks

Torsion springs

DASMA says the shaft a torsion spring is mounted on inherently provides containment.

Extension springs

DASMA says each spring needs a safety cable running through it, secured to the wall or ceiling at each end, to hold the spring if it breaks.

Read 8 Oct 2026: DASMA TDS-167 (PDF), DASMA safety tips.

03

Our price to replace

Torsion springs

Single spring, standard door: from $286.20 + $160 labor ($446.20 in all). Double spring, double-car garage: from $572.40 + $160 labor ($732.40 in all).

Extension springs

A pair: from $338.14.

Our figures: our price list.

04

Rated life

Torsion springs

Clopay says torsion springs generally last longer, often between 10,000 and 20,000 cycles.

Extension springs

Clopay says extension springs are less expensive but tend to wear out faster. It gives no cycle figure for them.

Read 8 Oct 2026: Clopay components guide.

05

Doing it yourself

Torsion springs

Do not attempt it. DASMA says spring systems should be repaired only by trained professionals.

Extension springs

Do not attempt it, for the same reason.

Read 8 Oct 2026: DASMA safety tips.

  • We fit springs rated for 20,000 to 30,000 cycles. Clopay says most garage door springs last 7 to 10 years with normal use, or about 10,000 cycles.

Where extension springs are the better choice

They cost less. Clopay calls extension springs less expensive, and on our price list a pair of extension springs starts at $338.14. A single torsion spring starts at $286.20 + $160 labor ($446.20 in all), and a double starts at $572.40 + $160 labor ($732.40 in all).

They are easy to check from the floor. You can see each spring along the track, and DASMA's check is simple: a cable running through the center of each spring, secured at both ends.

Check any of this yourself

Every outside fact on this page comes from one of these. Each takes a minute or two to check.

  1. Clopay's guide to door componentsHow each spring type works, and Clopay's cycle ratings for torsion springs.Read Clopay's guide
  2. DASMA safety tipsThe trade association on spring systems and extension spring safety cables.Read DASMA's safety tips
  3. DASMA TDS-167The trade association's data sheet on spring containment.Open the data sheet
  4. Our price listEvery Same Day price on this page.See the price list

Common questions about spring types

Spring broken? Call us.

Tell us which type you have, or send a photo. We will tell you the price before any work starts.

Safety and disclaimer. The repair guides and DIY information on this website are provided by Same Day Garage Door Services for general informational purposes only. They are not a substitute for an in-person inspection by a trained, licensed technician, and they may not fit your door, opener or situation.

Garage doors are the largest moving object in most homes. Springs (torsion and extension), lift cables, drums and bottom brackets operate under extreme tension and can cause serious injury, death or property damage if handled incorrectly. We strongly recommend that only a trained professional repair, adjust or replace these parts. Before any work on or near an opener, disconnect power (unplug it or switch off its breaker) and secure all remotes and keypads. Use the emergency release only as described in your opener's manual, preferably with the door closed, and never when a spring or cable may be broken. Keep children and pets clear, and never let children play with remotes or wall buttons.

Test your opener's automatic reversing system and safety sensors monthly, following your manufacturer's instructions. Residential garage door openers are subject to federal entrapment-protection requirements (16 CFR Part 1211, which incorporates UL 325). If your door does not reverse when it contacts an object or when the sensor beam is blocked, stop using the opener until it is repaired.

If you choose to do any work yourself, you do so at your own risk. Same Day Garage Door Services makes no warranty, express or implied, about the accuracy, completeness or fitness of this information for any purpose, and is not responsible for any injury, loss or damage resulting from its use, to the fullest extent allowed by law. Following a guide may void your manufacturer's warranty. Nothing here creates a service agreement or warranty; our warranties apply only to work we perform, under the terms in your written invoice.

In Arizona, paid garage door installation and repair work generally requires a license from the Arizona Registrar of Contractors (verify any contractor at roc.az.gov). Same Day Garage Door Services, ROC 308754 (primary) and ROC 349928. Questions? Call (480) 750-7975 or visit our scheduling page.